356. Walking vs Running: What the Research Says About the Runner’s High + Other Benefits of Both!
Newsletter coming! Get on the list: wellnesswhilewalking@gmail.com
If you ever wondered if you should be running or if you used to run but now can't, this episode is for you! There are benefits to both and they greatly overlap -- hear what the research says so you can choose what's right for you!
Please check back on the website for show notes -- had some tech glitches today and will fix asap! Be well!
Carolyn
Transcript
Some walkers ask themselves if they should be running.
Speaker:Other walkers are ex-runners who maybe would prefer to be running or doing both.
Speaker:We'll talk about what each activity has been found to do for us and what to do
Speaker:no matter what your run/walk dilemma or concerns are, including how to choose
Speaker:movement for the benefits we want.
Speaker:Let's step to it
Speaker:Welcome to the Wellness While Walking podcast.
Speaker:I'm your walking guide and health coach, Carolyn Cohen.
Speaker:Whether you've been walking or otherwise moving regularly, or it's fallen off
Speaker:your schedule, I'll be here to help you make your own wellness a priority.
Speaker:We'll plan for about a 30-minute walk each week, and while you're
Speaker:ambling, I'll be rambling in your ear.
Speaker:Mm-hmm, we will talk about walking a bit, but also about wellness in
Speaker:the largest sense of the word, so that we can continue on a journey
Speaker:of a beautiful life of no regrets.
Speaker:Let's chat, learn, laugh, and move in the most natural way possible,
Speaker:and then get back to designing and living the best, most rewarding
Speaker:lives we each ever imagined.
Speaker:Hi, welcome to episode 356.
Speaker:Thanks for being here with me today.
Speaker:Before we continue, a reminder that I'm not a doctor or mental health
Speaker:professional, and the content presented here is for educational
Speaker:and informational purposes only.
Speaker:Please make sure you check with your doctor before making any
Speaker:health or lifestyle changes.
Speaker:If you walk and part of you would rather be running or you're running
Speaker:curious, this conversation's for you.
Speaker:It's also for anyone who used to run and doesn't anymore, whether
Speaker:that was your decision or a decision your body made for you.
Speaker:Many of us have absorbed the idea that running is the serious form
Speaker:of exercise, and walking might be the form that we settle for.
Speaker:Maybe we even wonder at times if it counts as exercise.
Speaker:Today, we're going to look at what research says about these perceptions,
Speaker:what running gives people that they might miss when they don't do it
Speaker:anymore, and how we can choose our movement based on the benefits we want.
Speaker:We'll talk about the runner's high, the difference between the two activities
Speaker:as it relates to efficiency, and also their impact on the body, and a lot more.
Speaker:Even if you've not thought about adding running to your life or
Speaker:routine, we'll talk about some aspects of running that we might now wanna
Speaker:bring into our walks as we become more aware of them, so stay with me.
Speaker:Quick note, this is a two-part conversation.
Speaker:Today, we'll go through what people get from running and walking in
Speaker:terms of the benefits and also perhaps some potential pitfalls.
Speaker:And then next week, we'll personalize it all to you, what to do about your
Speaker:own weekly movement schedule depending on your preferences and situation Let's
Speaker:begin with a study that speaks directly to the worry that walking might not count.
Speaker:This comes up inevitably as when we talk about running, so let's
Speaker:face this concern right away.
Speaker:In 2013, researchers published a study that drew on two very large
Speaker:groups of people, the National Runners Study 2 and the National Walkers
Speaker:Health Study, and together that they included 50,000 runners and walkers.
Speaker:The participants filled out questionnaires about how much they ran or walked,
Speaker:and the researchers then followed them for about six years to see who
Speaker:was subsequently diagnosed with high blood pressure, high cholesterol,
Speaker:diabetes, or coronary heart disease.
Speaker:Running and walking use the same muscles and the same basic movement,
Speaker:but running does take more effort, so our bodies expend more energy
Speaker:in the same amount of time.
Speaker:So to compare these activities more evenly, the researchers estimated the
Speaker:energy each person spent from the distance that a person walked or ran instead.
Speaker:So when the researchers compared walkers and runners who spent the same amount
Speaker:of energy, walking showed larger risk reductions than running for high blood
Speaker:pressure, high cholesterol, and coronary heart disease, which, I don't know,
Speaker:I thought that was pretty surprising.
Speaker:And then the two were nearly identical for diabetes.
Speaker:And for all these effects, while they weren't huge, walking did relatively
Speaker:better by about, twice as much.
Speaker:So there are always caveats.
Speaker:The people in this study were volunteers.
Speaker:They might be more health-conscious than the general population and so on.
Speaker:Again, some of the absolute numbers were small.
Speaker:But I'd say at the same energy level spent, walking looked to be at least as
Speaker:protective as running for these measures.
Speaker:That's pretty awesome stuff for anyone who's concerned about
Speaker:their walking regimen helping them out as much as their neighbor's
Speaker:running routine does, for example.
Speaker:It's very easy to get caught up in the do more or do it harder mania, and I
Speaker:think this was a good reason to do you.
Speaker:But a runner hearing this might be thinking to themselves , "Well,
Speaker:I can be more efficient, uh, you know, when I run instead of walk."
Speaker:In this study, men who ran spent more than twice as much energy
Speaker:each day as men who walked.
Speaker:Running packs more energy into each hour, so reaching the same total
Speaker:through walking does take more minutes.
Speaker:One of the researchers pointed out that either walking or running
Speaker:is healthier than doing neither.
Speaker:I mean, okay, yeah, that's true for sure.
Speaker:But still it might be a niggling thought.
Speaker:You know, "If I ran, I'd be done more quickly."
Speaker:So going now to running, and we'll come back to the efficiency aspect, but going
Speaker:to running now and talking about its health benefits, one review that pooled
Speaker:14 studies and hundreds of thousands of people studied found that running was
Speaker:associated with about a 25% lower risk of death from any cause, 30% lower death
Speaker:from cardiovascular disease specifically, and 23% lower risk of death from cancer.
Speaker:Running was linked to a lower risk of death versus being sedentary at, every
Speaker:amount that the studies covered, including the lowest amount, which was about once
Speaker:a week or less than 50 minutes a week.
Speaker:The authors wrote that higher amounts of running may not necessarily
Speaker:bring greater benefit than what they found at those 50 minutes per week.
Speaker:As we're thinking about this, the US Federal Physical Activity Guidelines
Speaker:recommend 150 to 300 minutes a week of moderate intensity activity.
Speaker:They also state that 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous activity is
Speaker:the equivalent to those 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity.
Speaker:In other words, the guidelines themselves convey that a typical run essentially
Speaker:might deliver the same benefit as a typical walk in about half the time.
Speaker:Walkers can reach the same place with more minutes, and many of us
Speaker:find that trade-off to be worthwhile 'cause walking is easier to start
Speaker:and easier to keep doing, and we might find it more enjoyable.
Speaker:But we also can work to make walking more vigorous if we're trying to
Speaker:be more efficient with time and still get the cardio benefits.
Speaker:In fact, honestly, I know people are busy, but sometimes I, I
Speaker:have to think, like, what are we going to do with the time saved?
Speaker:I mean, if that's really the reason.
Speaker:Are we, that we're running is to save, I don't know, 20 to 30 minutes.
Speaker:Um, are we doing that just to have more time to be sedentary?
Speaker:' Cause when we look at it that way, maybe taking a prolonged
Speaker:walk isn't really the worst thing.
Speaker:After all, we might be logging more movement minutes and thus fewer
Speaker:sedentary or stationary m- minutes, by walking instead of running,
Speaker:by doing it less efficiently.
Speaker:I'm just saying, it's something to think about.
Speaker:Uh, let's also talk about VO2 max.
Speaker:It's the most oxygen your body can use during hard effort, and one of
Speaker:the main ways researchers measure how fit our lungs and heart are.
Speaker:A major 2009 analysis found that each small step up in fitness, as measured
Speaker:by VO2 max, was linked with about a 13% lower risk of death from any cause.
Speaker:So the lever for raising it is effort.
Speaker:In a randomized trial of about 250 middle-aged and older adults, alternating
Speaker:three minutes of fast walking with three minutes of easy walking raised
Speaker:walking fitness by about 9%, more than steady moderate walking did,
Speaker:which we've talked about before.
Speaker:And runners can use that same idea with hard intervals and,
Speaker:an easier recovery session.
Speaker:So VO2 max and fitness is affected by intensity of effort.
Speaker:So, so far we've looked at some of the things running gives us.
Speaker:We've also mixed in walking if walking was also a benefit.
Speaker:So let's now look at what running asks of our bodies.
Speaker:Runner's World, which is a magazine that's covered running
Speaker:for decades, has also written about how walking can help runners.
Speaker:For example, they published a piece titled "In Defense of
Speaker:Walking More and Running Less."
Speaker:The argument was that walking works much of the same muscle structure as
Speaker:running with similar movement patterns, but without the high impact forces
Speaker:that might cause injuries over time.
Speaker:They also noted that walking is weight-bearing, which matters for
Speaker:bone density, especially in women.
Speaker:And more and more runners are being urged to include walking in their regimens.
Speaker:I'll link to another well-respected thinker in the fitness space who's
Speaker:written extensively about running in the past, but who now stresses
Speaker:the importance of walking to round out his total approach to fitness.
Speaker:And on the topic of force or load on our joints that we just alluded to, when we
Speaker:walk, one foot's always on the ground.
Speaker:Even when we do those speedy race walk type motions, one
Speaker:foot's always on the ground.
Speaker:So let's talk about our, a fictitious friend, Joan, and
Speaker:go back a step from walking.
Speaker:Let's just talk about simple standing.
Speaker:So Joan needs to be able to withstand her body weight of 160 pounds of force,
Speaker:let's say, on her body just to stand, and we can thank gravity for that.
Speaker:If Joan then wants to walk, because the center of our body mass is
Speaker:moving when we walk, presumably forward, but also a little bit up
Speaker:and down, maybe side to side, that's more force than just standing.
Speaker:So it's been calculated that walking requires about 1.5%
Speaker:, times your body weight.
Speaker:So for Joan at 160, that's another 80 pounds, so 240 pounds of load for walking.
Speaker:Well, when we run, we're leaving the ground with each stride, right?
Speaker:There, there are times when n-neither of our feet are on the ground, and when we
Speaker:return to the ground with each stride, we can feel the impact of approximately
Speaker:two to three times our body weight.
Speaker:So Joan needs to withstand 320 to 480 pounds of force or load.
Speaker:I mean, that's potentially almost 500 pounds of force with each and every step.
Speaker:Now, this force can mean good things for us, such as bone strength.
Speaker:Running's repeated impacts can provide a very useful stimulus for bone, maintaining
Speaker:bone, and they're thinking even bone growth, and that really matters after
Speaker:menopause, especially when maintaining bone strength becomes just critical.
Speaker:A 2023 meta-analysis of 80 studies involving over 5,000 post-menopausal
Speaker:women found that structured exercise programs, primarily weightbearing
Speaker:activities, resistance training, impact exercise, or some combination
Speaker:of those modestly improved or preserved spine and hip bone mineral
Speaker:density compared with control groups.
Speaker:The review excluded swimming-only and cycling-only programs, and its
Speaker:re- results should not be interpreted as showing all activities produce
Speaker:the same bone benefit as each other.
Speaker:But it does look like having some sort of impact can be a
Speaker:helpful stimulus for healthy bone.
Speaker:But sometimes it can be more mixed.
Speaker:It can help, and it can also take a toll.
Speaker:So let's talk about its effects on joints first.
Speaker:The idea that running inevitably wears out your knees is not supported by research.
Speaker:Although running puts greater loads on the knee with each step, like we heard, than
Speaker:does walking, force alone does not tell us whether an activity will cause damage.
Speaker:The joint's ability to tolerate and adapt to that load is also relevant,
Speaker:and it's an individual thing.
Speaker:But another meta-analysis of many, many studies, including about 7,000
Speaker:runners and 7,000 non-runners, found no overall evidence that running worsened
Speaker:knee arthritis symptoms or imaging findings over the period studied.
Speaker:And non-runners actually reported more knee pain, and it wasn't clear
Speaker:whether the non-runners were walkers.
Speaker:It just said non-runners.
Speaker:And also fewer hip replacements, uh, were found by the runners.
Speaker:So these findings might be reassuring for any of us, but happily, the runners
Speaker:also happened to be on the older side.
Speaker:I think the average age was about 55, 56.
Speaker:So this isn't all about young'uns.
Speaker:It's not proof that running prevents arthritis, but it also doesn't
Speaker:mean necessarily that running can cause or will cause injuries or
Speaker:aggravate an individual joint.
Speaker:So I believe the practical message isn't avoid impact, but instead probably build
Speaker:a tolerable amount of loading and then - make sure that, , any persistent pain that
Speaker:we're facing is something that's assessed rather than pushed through and ignored.
Speaker:That beep indicates we're about halfway through the episode, so if
Speaker:you're not walking a loop, you might wanna turn around and head back now.
Speaker:Another front where I sometimes hear about force causing a
Speaker:problem is the pelvic floor.
Speaker:Running can challenge the pelvic floor.
Speaker:Challenging the pelvic floor isn't inherently good or bad.
Speaker:These muscles are meant to work while we move, including running, and research
Speaker:does confirm that the pelvic floor does have a response to running, but it hasn't
Speaker:established running as a reliable way to improve pelvic floor strength or support,
Speaker:particularly in women after menopause.
Speaker:So impact should not be automatically feared, but it sh- it also shouldn't,
Speaker:cause leakage or heaviness or, and, or any other issues as far as
Speaker:pelvic floor health and function go.
Speaker:So I do think these symptoms, uh, if we're feeling any while running, deserve
Speaker:assessment and an individual plan.
Speaker:Targeted pelvic floor training has better evidence for improving function
Speaker:of the pelvic floor and reducing leakage and so on than running does.
Speaker:So there are other ways to train the pelvic floor other than running.
Speaker:So I wouldn't do running to strengthen or preserve the function of the pelvic
Speaker:floor, but it also might not damage it.
Speaker:But I do think it's worth considering our pelvic floor strength situation
Speaker:if we're choosing high impact activities such as running.
Speaker:And then one more thing about force.
Speaker:Many runners, if not most, run repetitively on hard manmade surfaces.
Speaker:Now, you can argue that we were designed to run or move on a variety
Speaker:of surfaces, probably few of them being as hard as what, roads and
Speaker:sidewalks and pavement generally offers.
Speaker:We won't go into this now because it does op- open up like a ginormous
Speaker:tangent of, talking about the foot and, and footwear and so on, and we
Speaker:don't really have time for that today.
Speaker:But certainly it's something worth considering.
Speaker:Uh, it could be just another potential mismatch between our design and our
Speaker:environment Researchers have also asked whether running a lot could
Speaker:cut into the lower risk of death outcomes that we talked about earlier.
Speaker:One Danish study of, uh, over 1,000 joggers found sort of a U-shaped
Speaker:pattern with the lowest death rates among light joggers who jogged one
Speaker:to two and a half hours a week, and no better results than non-joggers
Speaker:among the most strenuous joggers.
Speaker:So in other words, the best were moderate joggers, and then
Speaker:non-joggers and the most strenuous joggers, they had fewer benefits.
Speaker:Um, that result was based on very few deaths occurring during the study
Speaker:period, so like two deaths among the 36 strenuous joggers, for example.
Speaker:So a study that counts deaths, I mean, it can't tell us a lot about other
Speaker:things between, you know, good health and death, like injuries or negative
Speaker:health effects of heavy running.
Speaker:So I mean, I would treat the U-shaped finding that the headlines talked
Speaker:a lot about at the time, but I, I would treat it as unproven - science.
Speaker:As always, though, I think the tendency for humans to just say like, "Well,
Speaker:if some is good, more is better," and I think in this case there's reason
Speaker:to believe that a sweet spot exists for lots of things, including maybe
Speaker:running, and after that more doesn't add more benefit and could potentially
Speaker:introduce some negative byproducts.
Speaker:So if more of one thing isn't always better, let's, let's talk about variety.
Speaker:The idea of mixing activities has some support in the research.
Speaker:In January of this year, researchers at Harvard's Chan School published a study,
Speaker:uh, that followed over 100,000 nurses and other health professionals for 30
Speaker:years, and they compared people who did the widest variety of physical activities
Speaker:with those who did the narrowest variety.
Speaker:After adjusting for the total amount of activity, the group with the most
Speaker:variety had about a 20% lower risk of death from any cause than the group
Speaker:that did fewer different activities.
Speaker:So this is, it's an association.
Speaker:It's not, like, a cause and effect necessarily, but it
Speaker:makes a lot of sense, right?
Speaker:Think about how our bodies evolved.
Speaker:We were hunter-gatherers.
Speaker:We moved all day and in a variety of ways, right?
Speaker:We crouched, we reached, we moved fast, we moved slow.
Speaker:We carried things in front of us.
Speaker:We carried things on top of us.
Speaker:We moved our bodies in all sorts of ways.
Speaker:So I do think it makes sense that a variety of movement will benefit
Speaker:us, but we'll definitely be coming back to that more in future episodes.
Speaker:The researchers also looked at individual activities, comparing
Speaker:people who did the most of each with people who did the least of each.
Speaker:Walking was linked to a 17% lower risk of death, racket sports 15%,
Speaker:running 13%, strength training also 13%, jogging 11%, and cycling 4%.
Speaker:Swimming showed no clear association.
Speaker:The lead author said the study wasn't designed to
Speaker:prescribe an ideal combination.
Speaker:What I take from it is that walking holds up well on its own and that mixing
Speaker:activities is probably worthwhile, which again, makes a ton of sense.
Speaker:Okay, so, so far we've looked at what the research says.
Speaker:Walking and running both lower the risk of several health problems, and when the
Speaker:same amount of energy is spent walking look to be at least as protective as
Speaker:running for blood pressure, cholesterol, diabetes, and heart disease, although
Speaker:walking does usually take more time.
Speaker:Running was linked to a lower risk of death even at small
Speaker:amounts with no clear sign that more running brings more benefit.
Speaker:We touched on VO2 max and how vigorous activity might increase
Speaker:our measures of cardiac fitness.
Speaker:We looked at what running asks of our body, more force with each step,
Speaker:joints that might handle it well or less so, a pelvic floor that
Speaker:we wanna pay more attention to.
Speaker:And people who mix different kinds of activity had a lower risk of death
Speaker:than people who stick to one kind.
Speaker:Well, let's talk now about what people miss when they stop running, because
Speaker:the physical health data from research studies just doesn't capture all of the,
Speaker:the benefits that p- actual people find.
Speaker:Many people who run or used to describe a feeling that goes beyond fitness.
Speaker:So health psychologist Kelly McGonigal wrote a book called The Joy of
Speaker:Movement, and she explores a whole bunch of these different phenomenon.
Speaker:And she calls the best known version of what a lot of people talk about as the
Speaker:biggest benefit of running a persistence high rather than a runner's high.
Speaker:And she describes it as a combination of using moderately hard effort, getting at
Speaker:least a slightly raised heart rate and about 20 minutes of sticking with it.
Speaker:People describe worries fading away, pain easing, optimism rising, and so on.
Speaker:The science behind that feeling has changed over time.
Speaker:For decades, the runner's high was credited to endorphins, the body's
Speaker:natural opioid-like chemicals.
Speaker:But in 2021, a study of over 50 people found that the euphoria
Speaker:occurred, even when endorphin, effects were blocked, which suggests
Speaker:that endorphins aren't required.
Speaker:And then attention shifted to other kind of chemicals, um, the endocannabinoids,
Speaker:which are like the body's own kind of cannabis-like, chemicals.
Speaker:And a 2023 review found that most of the studies that they were pooling
Speaker:showed higher endocannabinoids after a single bout of exercise,
Speaker:but also feel that the mechanism is, not quite ready for primetime.
Speaker:It's still being worked out exactly what's going on, but it
Speaker:is felt that it is related to endocannabinoids instead of endorphins.
Speaker:One of the best-known studies on endocannabinoids was published in
Speaker:2012, and it had only 10 people, along with some dogs and some
Speaker:ferrets run running and walking on a treadmill for about 30 minutes.
Speaker:I'm pretty sure this is the first time I have spoken about
Speaker:ferrets on Wellness While Walking.
Speaker:But anyway, in both people and dogs, a major endocannabinoid called
Speaker:anandamide rose after running.
Speaker:In people, it rose from about two to six picomoles per milliliter on average, which
Speaker:is meaningless to all of us probably other than to say, there was a relative rise of,
Speaker:of about, of inc- increasing threefold.
Speaker:It didn't rise after low-intensity walking.
Speaker:And ferrets showed no increase, which fits the idea that animals that are
Speaker:built for endurance get a reward from it.
Speaker:Us, you know, being dogs and people, so we would get a bigger rise
Speaker:in the endocannabinoid, which is linked with a bigger boost in mood.
Speaker:In this study, unfortunately, more vigorous walking wasn't tested, so we
Speaker:don't really know what a brisk walk would have done to those endocannabinoid levels.
Speaker:But now we know that ferrets aren't built for endurance.
Speaker:They're built for short bursts of activity and then long periods of rest,
Speaker:and they never in their evolution relied on long-distance persistence hunting
Speaker:to survive, and they didn't evolve the neurobiological drive to enjoy such
Speaker:prolonged running or vigorous activity.
Speaker:So that drive is, is built into us, though we might not feel it on some
Speaker:days, at least before we start.
Speaker:And maybe sometimes our lazy seeming dogs don't seem to either, but we were
Speaker:we evolved to have that drive, and it's rewarded by that endocannabinoid system.
Speaker:So that's another episode in the making maybe, but here we part with the
Speaker:ferret likely forever on this podcast.
Speaker:But here's to lifelong learning.
Speaker:You got to love it, ferrets and all.
Speaker:Let's carry on.
Speaker:A follow-up study also found that the effect of these feel-good endocannabinoids
Speaker:depended on intensity, with moderate effort producing increases and very low
Speaker:effort producing little of the substance.
Speaker:So scientists have also documented similar increases from cycling, from
Speaker:walking on a treadmill at an incline, which would be more challenging, right?
Speaker:And also outdoor hiking.
Speaker:So that's why McGonigal says the high isn't exclusive to running.
Speaker:She isn't a runner herself, and she claims that she gets a
Speaker:runner's type high from kickboxing, strength training, yoga, and dance.
Speaker:For those of us who walk, here's what I take away from this line of research.
Speaker:Effort levels do seem to matter.
Speaker:A leisurely walk at low effort didn't raise this chemical in the
Speaker:study, while brisker pace hills or hikes might get us closer.
Speaker:But to state the obvious, even without secreting this particular
Speaker:chemical, it doesn't mean that the walk doesn't have value.
Speaker:It still can leave us feeling good.
Speaker:Maybe we felt gratitude for the sunshine, awe at the flowers
Speaker:that we saw along the way.
Speaker:Maybe we felt a connection to another walker that, we
Speaker:smiled at when we passed them.
Speaker:Perhaps only a relative few of the millions of walks taken get to the level
Speaker:of being flooded with endocannabinoids, and yet we know there are infinite
Speaker:benefits of walks, of all kinds.
Speaker:And by the way, researchers have studied running much more than walking about this
Speaker:feeling, so we have a lot more to learn about how to make walks also generate
Speaker:the same feelings But in addition to McGonigal's observances, researchers
Speaker:have reported that these various different activities can be generated
Speaker:by other things other than running.
Speaker:So the good news is that it's a feeling, it's subjective, it's
Speaker:ours alone, and we can try all the things to see what we experience.
Speaker:And I hardly recommend waiting around for more research to come out because,
Speaker:you know, it may not apply to us for any number of reasons individually.
Speaker:We are best suited to figure out what feels good for us.
Speaker:So coming back to running, McGonigal describes other things running can offer.
Speaker:One is belonging.
Speaker:She says moving in sync with other people creates a collective joy, and that doing
Speaker:this regularly is more, , beneficial than a one and done, which makes sense.
Speaker:In one experiment described by TED Ideas, people who exercised for 30
Speaker:minutes before playing a sharing game shared more when they played,
Carolyn:after
Carolyn:Exercising first.
Carolyn:So it, it increased, good feelings and generosity, and that compounds because
Carolyn:we know when we give to others, our emotional wellbeing gets a bump up, so
Carolyn:it's kind of something that's nice to get.
Carolyn:Another benefit is a sense of mastery.
Carolyn:In an interview, she said that intensity amplifies that sense, and she asked
Carolyn:what the most challenging form of movement is that we can do and enjoy.
Carolyn:A third aspect is getting into music.
Carolyn:She says tempos of about 120 to 140 beats per minute are the most
Carolyn:motivating, and that lyrics about action or strength also help.
Carolyn:And then fourth is time outdoors, which she says calms rumination,
Carolyn:although she describes part of that idea as a little bit speculative.
Carolyn:She also describes what she calls hope molecules, which are these
Carolyn:myokines, chemicals that muscles release when they contract.
Carolyn:She says they act on the brain in ways that are similar to an antidepressant.
Carolyn:And we definitely have heard, , mood and movement are interrelated.
Carolyn:Her examples include walking, running, and lifting, so this benefit
Carolyn:is widely available, and there's heaps of research, like I said,
Carolyn:about the, beneficial psychological effects of all kinds of movement.
Carolyn:But it is interesting to know that these myokines are released when muscles
Carolyn:contract And then one more thing from McGonigal applies to anyone who's had to
Carolyn:stop a form of exercise that they loved.
Carolyn:She described a study way back in the '70s in which regular
Carolyn:exercisers were asked to cut back, and many reported mood disturbances.
Carolyn:She frames this as kind of a dependence and a mostly healthy one, but it
Carolyn:does mean that losing a form of movement that we rely on can feel
Carolyn:like losing a tool to help our mood and not just a fitness routine.
Carolyn:So figuring that out and understanding it if we have to give up something
Carolyn:that we've done is, you know, might help us decide what to replace.
Carolyn:And then she also brings up identity.
Carolyn:She says that the feedback our muscles gives us shapes our sense of self.
Carolyn:So choosing movement that expresses a quality we want, such as strength or
Carolyn:courage, might help us build that quality.
Carolyn:If part of what we miss about running is being a runner, McGonigal's point is
Carolyn:that maybe a different kind of movement could give us back that same quality.
Carolyn:We can look for movement that expresses the same quality, and maybe for running,
Carolyn:that's endurance or toughness or a feeling of freedom, and then find something else
Carolyn:, that might provide that same benefit or a feeling of identity around that.
Carolyn:So with all that in mind, I'd like to suggest a way of choosing our movement
Carolyn:that I'll call shopping for benefits.
Carolyn:Instead of asking whether walking or running is better, we can ask, , what
Carolyn:our movement, what we want to have it do for us, and we will be talking more
Carolyn:about that And like I said, that's when we'll be putting all of this to work.
Carolyn:Uh, we'll talk about all the benefits.
Carolyn:We'll talk about the five kinds of people, those who can't run now, those
Carolyn:who can't run for good, those who've drifted away from running, runners
Carolyn:who don't see a reason to walk, and walkers who wonder if they should try
Carolyn:running, and also walkers who don't.
Carolyn:So we will look at how all this information can help us, no matter
Carolyn:what we want to do going forward.
Carolyn:We'll talk about walking
Carolyn:and
Carolyn:running when it comes to weight.
Carolyn:We'll look at what thousands of walkers and runners have showed
Carolyn:us over the years of study.
Carolyn:I'll also talk about the hill that I'm going to be willing to die on
Carolyn:after seven years of hosting this podcast as it relates to walking.
Carolyn:But between now and then, I have a small homework challenge for
Carolyn:you if you choose to accept it.
Carolyn:Pick the one thing you want most from your movement.
Carolyn:Maybe it's a lift in mood or something you just need now and
Carolyn:maybe movement can provide it.
Carolyn:That might be a better way of thinking about it.
Carolyn:Do we need calm?
Carolyn:Do we need company?
Carolyn:Do we need a challenge?
Carolyn:Do we need more pleasure?
Carolyn:Make one small change this week that matches it.
Carolyn:It could be adding one brisk 20-minute walk.
Carolyn:It could be walking with a group.
Carolyn:It could be doing a little strength training.
Carolyn:And I think that will help us be prepared for the next episode where we'll go
Carolyn:into some more questions about what we're looking for and how we can match
Carolyn:activities to provide those things.
Carolyn:Remember, there's no one right way to do health, to do wellness, to do fitness.
Carolyn:Let's take a step this week and celebrate it.
Carolyn:After all, for that moment, we were walking against
Carolyn:traffic to be less sedentary.
Carolyn:That one step is so important and is even the biggest step of all.
Carolyn:So be well, and I will see you again next time.
Carolyn:The information provided by Wellness While Walking, Whole Life Workshop, and Bermuda
Carolyn:Road Wellness LLC is for informational and entertainment purposes only.
Carolyn:It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical
Carolyn:advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
Carolyn:Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare
Carolyn:provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or
Carolyn:treatment and before undertaking any new healthcare regimen, including walking.
